There are very few, if any, clinical trials comparing photons with protons or ions heavier than protons such as C-ions. Currently, the selection of the patients for proton therapy is based on the assumed better physical conformity of the proton plans in comparison to photons. The specific aim of this project is to create the framework and perform in silico clinical trials protons versus photons that would provide objective criteria to select patients for proton therapy including the analysis of the robustness of the photon and proton plans to uncertainties in the physical and biological parameters, the optimisation of the proton plans with respect to LET and the optimisation of the plans with respect to the adverse radiobiological features.